George Pickens Trade: A Game-Changer for Cowboys and Steelers
In a move that has sent ripples through the NFL community, the Pittsburgh Steelers have agreed to trade their talented yet unpredictable wide receiver, George Pickens, along with a 2027 sixth-round pick, to the Dallas Cowboys. In return, the Steelers will receive a 2026 third-rounder and a 2027 fifth-rounder. This trade, finalized on a quiet Wednesday morning, marks one of the most significant transactions of the 2025 offseason.
George Pickens, a second-round pick from Georgia in 2022, has had a rollercoaster three-year career with the Steelers. During his tenure, he recorded 174 receptions, 2,841 yards, and 12 touchdowns, including an impressive 1,140-yard season in 2023. However, his time in Pittsburgh was not without its challenges. Pickens often expressed dissatisfaction with the Steelers’ offensive strategies and faced criticism for his perceived lack of effort.
As Pickens departs Pittsburgh, he leaves a void in the Steelers’ lineup but gains a fresh start with the Cowboys. ESPN NFL reporters Todd Archer, Jeremy Fowler, and Brooke Pryor have shared their insights on what this trade means for both teams and Pickens himself.
Why Did the Steelers Move On from Pickens?
The Steelers had been exploring trade options for Pickens even before the draft, but negotiations stalled when they couldn’t secure the desired value. By trading him now, the Steelers avoid a potentially contentious offseason, especially with Pickens entering the final year of his rookie contract and eligible for an extension. While the Steelers initially wanted to keep Pickens, extending his contract could have led to drama if both parties couldn’t agree on terms.
Despite his on-field productivity, Pickens’ conduct raised concerns. He frequently clashed with coaches over his sideline antics and costly celebrations. Notably, during a Week 13 game against the Bengals, he was penalized twice for unsportsmanlike conduct. Additionally, he arrived late to the stadium before a Christmas Day game against the Kansas City Chiefs.
Steelers coach Mike Tomlin commented on Pickens’ behavior, saying, “He’s just got to grow up, man. This is an emotional game, man. These divisional games are big. He’s got a target on his back because he’s George; he understands that. But he’s got to grow up. He’s got to grow up in a hurry.” — Pryor
How Does Pickens Fit into the Cowboys’ Offense?
The Cowboys were eager to inject some “juice” into their offense, particularly in terms of speed to complement CeeDee Lamb. Pickens, who ran a 4.47 40-yard dash at the 2022 NFL combine, led the league in yards per catch in 2023 with an average of 18.1.
According to ESPN Research, Pickens ranks third in receiving yards on vertical routes since 2022, trailing only the Dolphins’ Tyreek Hill and Vikings’ Justin Jefferson. His 15.3 yards per catch last season were the sixth highest among players with 50 or more receptions. The last time the Cowboys had a receiver with similar stats was Michael Gallup in 2019. — Archer
Impact on the Steelers’ Offense and Aaron Rodgers Recruitment
At recent league meetings, the Steelers emphasized that acquiring DK Metcalf was more about building a strong wide receiver duo than a reflection on Pickens’ future. However, trading Pickens leaves the Steelers with only one top receiver, Metcalf, on their roster.
Without another major acquisition, the Steelers’ wide receiver depth is thin, with Calvin Austin III being the top returning receiver with 548 yards. While Metcalf is a proven player, the Steelers also have tight end Pat Freiermuth and an offensive coordinator known for maximizing tight end potential.
Though Pickens and Metcalf could have formed a dynamic duo, the Steelers aim for a balanced offense with a strong running game. They drafted Iowa running back Kaleb Johnson and signed Kenneth Gainwell. While Pickens’ departure might reduce explosive plays, it could stabilize the offense.
Pickens’ absence is unlikely to affect the Steelers’ pursuit of Aaron Rodgers. The team has maintained communication with Rodgers, who is known for demanding precise route running from his receivers. Pickens’ history of route issues might have clashed with Rodgers’ expectations. — Pryor
Options for Steelers’ Wide Receiver Recruitment
With the draft concluded, the Steelers have limited options for acquiring a wide receiver. However, they have three third-round picks in next year’s draft, which could be used in a trade for a veteran receiver. Potential targets include DJ Moore from the Bears or Brandon Aiyuk, whose market might be affected by an ACL injury.
On the free agent market, Keenan Allen and Amari Cooper are potential candidates. Cooper, in particular, could be a good fit for the Steelers’ new quarterback, presumably Rodgers. — Fowler
Why Did the Cowboys Delay Addressing Their WR2 Spot?
Many have questioned the Cowboys’ timing in addressing their WR2 position. However, Pickens only missed the initial weeks of the Cowboys’ offseason program. The Cowboys had plans to draft Tetairoa McMillan but were outmaneuvered by the Carolina Panthers. The Cowboys prefer not to spend heavily in free agency and had discussions with several teams before finalizing the deal with the Steelers.
Among the Cowboys’ receivers, Jalen Tolbert is likely to be most affected by Pickens’ arrival. Tolbert had 49 catches for 610 yards and led the team with seven touchdowns last season. If the Cowboys’ passing game thrives under Dak Prescott, Tolbert’s previous numbers would be acceptable for a No. 3 wideout. — Archer
Pickens’ Contract Realities and Future in Dallas
By trading a third-round pick, the Cowboys are not looking for a one-year rental in Pickens. However, Fowler reports that the Cowboys do not plan to extend Pickens’ contract and expect him to complete his rookie deal.
The Cowboys face contract negotiations with several key players, including edge rusher Micah Parsons, tight end Jake Ferguson, and cornerback DaRon Bland, all entering the final year of their contracts. With only one franchise tag available, the Cowboys must be strategic.
In the past, the Cowboys have successfully retained key receivers, such as Amari Cooper, with lucrative deals. With CeeDee Lamb already earning $34 million annually, the Cowboys must decide how much they are willing to invest in Pickens. — Archer
Originally Written by: Todd Archer,Brooke Pryor
