Pete Carroll is back in the NFL! Why the Raiders made the hire, plus our grade and what’s next.

Why Pete Carroll is the Right Choice for the Raiders

In the ever-evolving world of the NFL, the Las Vegas Raiders have made a significant move by bringing in veteran coach Pete Carroll. The news broke on January 24, 2025, when ESPN’s Adam Schefter reported that Carroll and the Raiders had reached an agreement for him to become the franchise’s head coach on a three-year deal with a fourth-year team option. This decision marks a pivotal moment for the Raiders, who are in the midst of a rebuild and in desperate need of stability.

Carroll, who will turn 74 on September 15, is no stranger to success. He is one of only three head coaches to have led a team to both a national championship in college (USC) and a Super Bowl title (Seattle Seahawks). The other two coaches who share this distinction are Barry Switzer and Jimmy Johnson. Carroll’s impressive track record makes him a valuable asset for the Raiders as they look to turn their fortunes around.

Since the Raiders moved to Las Vegas from Oakland in 2020, they have gone through a revolving door of head coaches. Carroll will be the fifth coach, including interims, to take the helm since the move. The franchise has struggled to find stability, and Carroll’s veteran presence is expected to provide the leadership and consistency the team desperately needs.

What Makes Carroll the Ideal Hire?

The Raiders have been searching for stability, and Carroll is poised to deliver just that. Despite his age, Carroll’s youthful exuberance and positive attitude have been major selling points. His presence lit up the Raiders facility during his interview, according to team sources. Carroll’s extensive experience and accomplishments make him a known commodity, something the Raiders have been missing since Jon Gruden’s departure.

In a division with coaching heavyweights like Andy Reid, Sean Payton, and Jim Harbaugh, Carroll’s résumé stacks up well. His Super Bowl XLVIII title, two NFC championships, and 10 playoff appearances in 14 years with the Seahawks speak volumes about his ability to lead a team to success. While immediate postseason success may not be expected, Carroll’s experience is anticipated to make the Raiders a more respectable team.

The Role of Tom Brady in the Hiring Process

Tom Brady, a minority owner of the Raiders, played a role in the hiring process, albeit indirectly. While Brady owns only about 10% of the team, his influence is significant. There is speculation that Brady was more involved in the hiring of John Spytek as the Raiders’ general manager, given their history as college teammates and front office colleagues with the Buccaneers. Ultimately, the final decision rested with owner Mark Davis, but Brady’s presence in the decision-making process cannot be overlooked.

Challenges Ahead for Carroll

One of the most pressing issues Carroll faces is the quarterback situation. While Aidan O’Connell has shown promise, the Raiders need an upgrade to compete in the AFC West, which features quarterbacks like Patrick Mahomes, Justin Herbert, and Bo Nix. The possibility of Russell Wilson joining the Raiders as a bridge quarterback has been floated, given his past success with Carroll in Seattle.

With the No. 6 pick in the draft, the Raiders have an opportunity to address their quarterback needs. However, the availability of top prospects like Shedeur Sanders and Cam Ward remains uncertain. Carroll’s choice of offensive coordinator will also be crucial in shaping the team’s offensive strategy, especially with first-team All-Pro tight end Brock Bowers in the mix.

Defensively, Carroll and Spytek will need to make decisions regarding the team’s free agents, including defensive ends Malcolm Koonce and K’Lavon Chaisson, linebackers Robert Spillane and Divine Deablo, cornerback Nate Hobbs, and safeties Tre’von Moehrig and Marcus Epps. Fortunately, the Raiders have over $108 million in salary cap space to work with.

Carroll’s Coaching Style and Impact

Carroll is known for being a culture builder and a winner. His ability to create a positive and consistent environment was evident during his tenure with the Seahawks. Players appreciated his upbeat energy and the way he took care of veterans, making him the ultimate players’ coach. Carroll’s approach will be invaluable for a young, rebuilding Raiders team.

While some critics may question Carroll’s recent lack of title contention, his .599 winning percentage over 14 seasons (147-98-1, including playoffs) is a testament to his coaching prowess. Carroll’s ability to instill confidence in his players will be crucial as he leads the Raiders through their rebuilding phase.

League Reactions to Carroll’s Hiring

Carroll’s interview with the Raiders went exceptionally well, with the Super Bowl-winning coach presenting a compelling vision for the team’s future. The general consensus around the league is that Carroll was the best option for the Raiders after missing out on Ben Johnson, who became the head coach of the Chicago Bears. Carroll’s high energy and credibility make him a valuable asset for the franchise, even if he may not be a long-term solution.

Draft Prospects and the Quarterback Dilemma

The Raiders enter the offseason with a pressing need at quarterback. With the No. 6 pick in the 2025 draft, they have the opportunity to address this need. However, the availability of top prospects like Miami’s Ward and Colorado’s Sanders remains uncertain. The lack of a consensus QB3 in the draft adds complexity to the situation, making it a risky proposition for the Raiders to wait until draft day to address their quarterback needs.

Grading the Hire

B. While Carroll’s hiring may not be the most glamorous, it is precisely what the Raiders need. His experience, track record, and winning formula will help elevate the team from its recent struggles. Carroll’s ability to adapt and innovate, as demonstrated during his time in Seattle, makes this a solid hire for the Raiders.